Warranty of title

The sale of real property, such as land, buildings, and other types of real estate, generally comes with a warranty of title (leases come with a warranty for possession and use). A general warranty deed guarantees that the title to the property is free from any claims. If another party such as a bank has a lien against the property, then the seller will offer a quitclaim deed, which makes no assurances as to the title of the property and protects the seller from potential liability to the buyer if a claim is made on the property. Otherwise, the seller is liable as guaranteeing transfer of title free from any encumbrances. A special warranty deed ensures that no claims were made against the property while in the possession of the current owner. As to buildings, warranties may be made about the quality of materials, the adherence to building codes, and its ability to accommodate residents. The latter is an implied warranty of habitability that exists with any lease of residential property. The landlord is responsible for providing conditions necessary for living (e.g., water, heat, electricity, and safety requirements), and tenants may withhold rent if said warranty is breached.

A warranty of title also exists for the sale of goods (or a lease warranty for use and possession). Although the warranty is implicitly conveyed with the sale of the good, it is not identified as an implied warranty and may be disclaimed by a clearly communicated writing. However, in some instances the events surrounding a purchase eliminate the warranty of title, such as the purchase of goods from a sheriff’s sale (court-ordered auction). A related warranty against infringement exists for merchants who sell patents or types of intellectual property and warrants that the goods are passed without any claim of a third person as to infringement on the property rights.

Express warranties

Under the UCC, a seller creates an express warranty by any promise, description, or use of sample or model that relates to the goods and becomes part of the basis of the bargain. Thus, representations about the quality of a product, its uses, and whether it is new or used are all warranties. For example, representations about gas mileage create a warranty about a car’s performance in the sale of that good. Software licenses commonly contain express warranties about the software’s material conformity to certain specifications. However, the licensor often limits the warranty with problems surrounding installation, operation, transit, modification, and hardware.

Advertisements, free samples, models, and other sales materials may also create express warranties. Samples come directly from the group of products to be purchased, whereas a model is a representation of the product when a specific sample is unavailable. International companies must pay close attention to their use of samples and models, as they play a significant role in international sales and are given special recognition under the CISG.

The specificity of the claim made is a major factor in determining if a warranty has in fact been manifested. Opinions do not create a warranty unless offered by an expert, and statements of general opinion or clearly exaggerated claims (called puffery) are not considered warranties. Express warranties reduced to writing cannot be waived by a contradictory disclaimer. However, oral warranties may be waived by clear and conspicuous language under the UCC and by less formal methods under the CISG.

Implied warranties

As stated earlier, implied warranties are not expressly represented in the written or oral sales agreement but are created and imposed through application of law, usually the UCC. The two primary implied warranties that accompany the sale or lease of goods are that of “merchantability” and that of “fitness for a particular purpose.”

The warranty of merchantability obliges the merchant to sell or lease goods that pass without objection, are of average and uniform quality, fit for the ordinary purpose of such goods, are adequately packaged and labeled, and conform to promises made on the label. The warranty occurs automatically on the sale and need not be the basis for the bargain.

Most implied warranties can be waived orally or in writing but must conspicuously specify the word merchantability when disclaiming that specific warranty. Other warranties may also be waived by “as is” language or by a course of dealing that disallows the warranty. For instance, most directly downloadable software license agreements contain a warranty waiver or disclaimer that must be agreed to before the software can in fact be downloaded.

The implied warranty for fitness for a particular purpose (which obviously differs from the ordinary purpose standard of the warranty of merchantability) applies when a buyer relies on the seller’s skill or judgment in choosing a product for a particular purpose and when the seller knows or should know the buyer’s purpose. For example, bicycle buyers explain how they need a bike that can handle a certain type of mountain terrain. In recommending a certain type of bike, the salesperson is held to an implied warranty of fitness for a particular purpose (of the bike’s ability to handle mountain terrain). If the bike cannot actually perform as expected, the implied warranty for fitness for a particular purpose has been breached, and the buyers could most likely return the bike.

This warranty may also be waived by a piece of writing that says “as is” or “with all faults,” though an oral waiver is insufficient. Refusal to examine the goods for defects waives any implied warranties, and a buyer who assumes a discovered and known risk is precluded from recovering damages resulting from such use. Although the seller may limit certain remedies that the buyer has for breach of warranty, the seller may not limit or exclude the buyer’s right to damages from injury or try to shorten the statute of limitations.

American law and international law provide means to avoid some of the problems of disclaimers, waivers, and misunderstood or deceptive warranties. In the U.S. the federal Magnuson-Moss Warranty Act of 1975 requires sellers of consumer products to articulate clearly and simply the coverage of the warranty, to identify it as a full or limited guarantee of repair or replacement, and to retain all implied warranties when providing a written warranty of any sort. For example, if a company provides a written warranty for its toys, the company cannot disclaim the implied warranties. Internationally, the CISG contains similar warranty provisions: The seller must provide goods that (1) are fit for the ordinary purpose of such goods, (2) are fit for any particular purpose made known, (3) possess the same qualities of a model or sample, and (4) are packaged in the normal manner for such goods. The packaging is especially important in light of international deliveries. However, to find a breach, the CISG demands a more substantial deviation than what the UCC requires.