Nixon resigns: Watergate’s legacy
At 9:00 pm on Thursday, August 8, 1974, Washington Post reporters Bob Woodward and Carl Bernstein joined other Post journalists watching television screens that hung from the ceiling of the newsroom as Pres. Richard Nixon announced from the White House that he would resign the presidency of the United States the next day at noon. The only U.S. president ever to resign, Nixon was replaced by his vice president, Gerald Ford.
Although Woodward, 31, and Bernstein, 30, had played a significant role in Nixon’s downfall, they had no work to do that night. Their investigative reporting of the Watergate scandal over the past two years had been done as part of the Post’s local news staff. The June 17, 1972, burglary of the Democratic National Committee headquarters in the Watergate complex had started out as a seemingly petty local crime in Washington. It was Woodward and Bernstein’s reporting over the next two years that would connect the crime to the White House. Now, the newspaper’s national news staff, which had long doubted the two young journalists’ investigative reporting, had taken over what had become a historic political story.
In the autumn of 1972, Woodward and Bernstein were virtually alone in the American news media in their investigation of Watergate. No one could envision that it might ever lead to anything like Nixon’s resignation. But, as Woodward later recalled, he and Bernstein were alone in the newsroom’s small canteen almost two years before that historic August evening, reviewing their investigative progress, when Bernstein suddenly said, “Oh, my God, the president is going to be impeached.”
“Jesus, I think you’re right,” Woodward responded, adding, “We can never use that word in the newsroom.”
Pressure from without—and within
Spoken speculation about Nixon being impeached—much less resigning—would have further isolated the two reporters and their few editors on the local news staff from their newsroom colleagues. At the time, most of the Post’s national news reporters and their competitors in Washington gave deference to what they were told by their sources in government and politics, whom they knew well. They regarded the Watergate break-in as the kind of “dirty tricks” that were commonplace in politics.
“We did these stories that no one believed.”
—Bob Woodward on Watergate reporting
Woodward and Bernstein were not constrained by that culture. They developed techniques that would become basic tools for investigative reporters long afterward. They worked on Watergate from the bottom up, piecing together information from low-level government and Nixon reelection sources into patterns of criminality before confronting higher officials. They often showed up at the homes of reluctant sources and talked their way inside. They found ways to obtain telephone, travel, and hotel records. (The Internet would not come to The Washington Post newsroom for two more decades.)
“We were alone,” Woodward recalled in a 2024 interview for this Encyclopaedia Britannica article. “Our colleagues at the Post doubted us. We did these stories that no one believed.”
The Nixon White House and Republican Party leaders repeatedly attacked the Post for its Watergate stories. Nixon’s press secretary, Ron Zeigler, accused the Post of publishing stories “based on hearsay, innuendo, guilt by association.” Reporters on the newspaper’s national news staff were told by their government sources that Woodward and Bernstein were in over their heads.
Post publisher Katharine Graham was warned by friends and business colleagues that the Watergate stories could ruin her newspaper and television station company. Friends of Nixon in Florida filed formal challenges against Post ownership of television stations there. “During these months, the pressures on The Post to cease and desist were intense and uncomfortable, to say the least,” Graham later wrote in her memoir, Personal History (1997). She nevertheless trusted Post executive editor Ben Bradlee, who protected Woodward and Bernstein and their local news editors from outside attacks and doubts inside the newsroom.
A tipping point
Then, on October 27 and 28, 1972, CBS Evening News anchor Walter Cronkite—who had been described as the most trusted man in America—devoted an unprecedented 14 minutes at the top of his newscast to a tutorial about the Watergate story for his national audience, followed by 8 minutes in his newscast the following night. A corner was turned.
Nixon was reelected in the November 7, 1972, presidential election by a landslide, with more than 60 percent of the popular vote and all electoral votes except those from Massachusetts and the District of Columbia. But after Cronkite’s broadcasts Woodward and Bernstein were gradually joined by competing reporters from other news media in investigating the Watergate burglary, its cover-up with hush money payments to the burglars, wiretaps of people on Nixon’s “enemies list,” and other political crimes instigated by the Nixon White House.
That led to investigations by federal special prosecutors and a bipartisan Senate Select Committee on Presidential Campaign Activities, which produced more revelations, including the existence of what turned out to be secret White House tape recordings that incriminated Nixon and his top aides in the Watergate cover-up. The 51 days of televised Senate Watergate hearings in the late spring through autumn of 1973 captured the nation’s attention.
Washington also was shocked by what became known as the Saturday Night Massacre. On Saturday night, October 20, 1973, Nixon ordered the Justice Department to fire Watergate special prosecutor Archibald Cox, who was seeking the Nixon White House tapes. After Attorney General Elliot Richardson and Deputy Attorney General William Ruckelshaus refused and resigned, Solicitor General Robert Bork carried out Nixon’s order. Later, Bork appointed as special prosecutor Leon Jaworski, who vigorously pursued the investigation of the Nixon White House crimes.
In the end 48 men, including top officials in the White House, were convicted of crimes connected to the Watergate scandal. The House of Representatives was ready to impeach Nixon for obstruction of justice, abuse of power, and contempt of Congress, and the Senate appeared likely to convict him. Nixon resigned after a unanimous U.S. Supreme Court ordered him to turn over tape recordings that revealed Nixon ordering his chief of staff to tell the CIA to fabricate reasons to stop an FBI investigation of Watergate.
On September 8, 1974, a month after his resignation, Nixon was pardoned by President Ford for the crimes he had committed. Woodward said that Ford told him in an interview afterward that he did so because “I needed my own presidency.”
Ford became the only person to serve as president and vice president without being elected to either office. Nixon had appointed Ford vice president after Vice Pres. Spiro Agnew resigned on October 10, 1973, as part of a federal court plea deal for accepting bribes when he was governor of Maryland.
Watergate as coda to a chaotic decade
Nixon’s resignation climaxed a tumultuous period in U.S. history. In the 1960s and early 1970s, the country had divided deeply over the civil rights and counterculture movements and the long Vietnam War. It had experienced the assassinations of Pres. John F. Kennedy in 1963 and Martin Luther King, Jr., and Robert F. Kennedy in 1968, along with the riots after King’s death and years of anti-war demonstrations throughout the country. Pres. Lyndon B. Johnson announced on March 31, 1968, that he had decided not to run for reelection later that year because “there is division in the American house now” over the war.
Unrest continued, when, on May 4, 1970, four Kent State University students were killed as Ohio National Guard troops fired on them during an anti-war rally on its Ohio campus. In 1973, after more than 58,200 American deaths in Vietnam, the last U.S. troops finally left the southeast Asian country, and the unpopular military draft that had pulled them into the war was ended.
Nixon’s resignation further unsettled the country, and its impact reverberated through the next half century. “It changed history,” Woodward said in an interview. “It was a red light for presidents.”
Some ran through the red light. The only president who had been impeached by the House of Representatives before Nixon was Andrew Johnson in 1868, and he was acquitted by the Senate by one vote. However, in the half century after Watergate, presidents Bill Clinton and Donald Trump also were impeached by the House and acquitted by the Senate. They and other presidents after Nixon often were investigated by reporters, Congress, or special prosecutors.
“It had a cumulative impact on the press, the government, and the system,” Woodward said. “It legitimized in-depth investigative reporting.”
Enduring legacy to journalism and politics
Before Watergate, there were relatively few investigative reporters who produced primarily local exposés. Reporting about government, for example, consisted mostly of what journalists were told at news conferences and briefings and in statements by official spokespeople.
After Watergate, investigative reporting became a priority for most American news media, even as they eventually endured disruption by economic and digital change. Investigative teams were created by newspapers, broadcast outlets, and online news organizations.
Reporters investigated every aspect of American society—from governments and their secrets, and politics and politicians to business and finance, law enforcement and courts, education and health, religion and culture, and even sports. Investigative reporting aggressively challenged government and corporate secrecy and probed questionable private behavior of politicians and public figures. It exposed festering societal ills, including the victimization of women in the workplace and the sexual crimes of Catholic priests.
In 1975, a group of American investigative journalists started Investigative Reporters and Editors (IRE), which trains and provides research resources for thousands of journalists across the nation and around the world. Investigative reporting teams also sprouted in other countries. Reporters increasingly collaborated with those at other news organizations nationally and internationally on larger and larger investigations.
Woodward and Bernstein’s best-selling book, All the President’s Men (1974), and the movie (1976), in which Robert Redford and Dustin Hoffman played the two reporters, made them celebrities and glamorized their work. Over time, they and increasingly more journalists wrote books about what they had reported in the news media. And they began appearing with increasing frequency on television news talk shows. New scandals were often christened with the suffix -gate.
Some observers expressed concern that investigative reporters were sometimes motivated to go too far. “After a generation of journalists that had probably trusted government too much,” historian Garrett M. Graff wrote in his authoritative book Watergate: A New History (2022), “came a generation of journalists who seemed to believe that Watergates existed inside every government office and corporate headquarters.”
Yet investigative journalism has led to countless reforms of all kinds. Watergate and Nixon’s resignation also prompted Congress to enact laws enabling the appointment of special prosecutors and the protection of federal government whistleblowers who expose wrongdoing. Congress and many states passed or strengthened freedom of information and open meetings laws, although there often have been disputes with the news media over their enforcement.
Congress became more vigorous in investigating other parts of the government. “Beyond the presidency, the Watergate investigations also tore away the protective cloak of secrecy that had long kept politicians from delving too deeply into the work of the country’s law enforcement and intelligence agencies,” Graff wrote in his book. Congress exposed, for example, domestic spying by the CIA and FBI on political dissenters, civil rights organizers, women’s rights advocates, and others.
What began as the investigation of an office burglary in the Watergate by two Washington Post local news reporters led to decades of profound national political and journalistic change.