Films of the 2010s: Shutter Island, Hugo, and The Wolf of Wall Street

Shutter Island (2010) starred DiCaprio as a U.S. marshal who in 1954 travels to a psychiatric facility isolated in Boston Harbor to search for a missing patient. However, it soon becomes clear that what began as a noirish detective story has become something much closer to a horror movie. DiCaprio’s hard-boiled mien played well against Ben Kingsley’s Dr. Cawley, the crafty, evasive director of the gothic facility. Michelle Williams, Max von Sydow, and Jackie Earle Haley also provided top-notch support. The film was as much a box-office smash as The Departed, but reviews were not as universally enthusiastic.

Hugo (2011) was a radical departure for Scorsese. Based on Brian Selznick’s young-adult novel The Invention of Hugo Cabret, the film was Scorsese’s first shot in 3-D and was easily the most expensive production he had ever undertaken, with costs estimated as high as $170 million. In 1931 Paris 12-year-old orphan Hugo (Asa Butterfield) lives inside the recesses of the Gare Montparnasse train station, an enormous complex filled with many shops. One of these is a small toy store run by a cantankerous old man (Kingsley). The old man is eventually revealed to be the once-celebrated pioneer filmmaker Georges Méliès, who remains bitter about the destruction of so much of his life’s work and since has lived as a near-recluse. But aided by Méliès’s charming niece (Chloë Grace Moretz) and the efforts of a film scholar, Hugo eventually manages to bring Méliès back into the world. (The subject of regaining film’s lost heritage was important to Scorsese, who in 1990 had founded the Film Foundation, dedicated to preserving American films, and in 2007 the World Cinema Foundation, dedicated to preserving films from around the world.) Hugo was nominated for 11 Oscars, the most of any 2011 film, including nods for best picture and best director.

Scorsese won an Emmy Award for another of his musical documentaries, George Harrison: Living in the Material World (2011), which examined the life of the former Beatle. Scorsese branched out further into television as the executive producer of Boardwalk Empire (2010–14), an HBO drama series about gangsters in Atlantic City during Prohibition. He also directed the show’s first episode, for which he received an Emmy in 2011.

He returned to his familiar New York City haunts with The Wolf of Wall Street (2013), a cautionary tale based on the memoir by Jordan Belfort (DiCaprio), a stock trader who fell afoul of the law but not before showering himself and his associates in tremendous wealth. The film divided critics, who saw it as either condemning or celebrating Belfort and his excesses. Scorsese received his eighth Oscar nomination for best director, and the film itself was nominated for best picture. He returned to television as an executive producer of HBO’s Vinyl (2016), about the exploits of a record company executive (Bobby Cannavale) in 1970s New York City. He directed that show’s first episode as well. Also in 2016, he was given the prestigious Praemium Imperiale award for his career in film.

Scorsese next helmed and cowrote the feature film Silence (2016), which was based on a novel by Endō Shūsaku. The epic drama—which Scorsese had wanted to make for nearly 30 years—continued his exploration of faith. It centers on Jesuit missionaries in 17th-century Japan who face torture or death if they do not renounce Catholicism. Many critics praised the film as among Scorsese’s better works. In 2019 Scorsese directed the documentary Rolling Thunder Revue: A Bob Dylan Story by Martin Scorsese, recounting the musician’s freewheeling 1975 tour. Later that year The Irishman appeared, first in theaters and then on Netflix. The mob drama reunited Scorsese with De Niro and Pesci, and it marked the first time he directed Al Pacino. The film, which received widespread acclaim, centers on a hit man (De Niro) who allegedly killed labor leader Jimmy Hoffa (Pacino). The Irishman garnered 10 Oscar nominations, including one for best picture. In addition, Scorsese earned his ninth nod for best director.

Films of the 2020s: Killers of the Flower Moon

In 2021 Scorsese directed and appeared in the docuseries Pretend It’s a City, about humorist Fran Lebowitz, a longtime friend. In the seven-part series, which was filmed during the COVID-19 pandemic, Lebowitz discusses her life and New York City. Pretend It’s a City was Scorsese’s second project involving Lebowitz; Public Speaking, a documentary movie, appeared in 2010.

In 2023 Scorsese returned to crime dramas with Killers of the Flower Moon, which recounts the real-life murders of Osage tribal members in the 1920s. After oil was discovered on their reservation, the Oklahoma tribe became hugely wealthy—and the target of criminals who sought to claim their land rights. The widely praised drama, which was based on a book by David Grann, starred two of Scorsese’s most-frequent collaborators, De Niro and DiCaprio. Its female lead, Lily Gladstone, earned a Golden Globe Award for best actress, becoming the first Indigenous person to win the award. The film was nominated for 10 Oscars, including best picture and best director.

Legacy

Despite the diversity in his chosen subject matter, Scorsese’s work contains common elements. His simultaneous fondness for and rebellion against old Hollywood is demonstrated by his exploring anew clichéd plot devices that often culminate in bleak irony and moral ambiguity. He has been praised for his use of the subjective camera to portray the protagonist’s point of view, an approach characterized by such subtle touches as right-to-left camera pans that move contrary to normal eye movement and thereby create a slightly disconcerting effect and suggest a subjectively distorted world. Scorsese’s films tend to be concerned with people rather than plots, and he is fond of placing his characters in volatile situations and allowing events to unfold naturally, as determined by the characters’ instincts, lusts, and obsessions. One of the most important filmmakers of the late 20th and early 21st centuries, Scorsese reflects in his work both a cynicism toward modern culture and an obvious love of the cinema.